“We are not at ease”: Demands for stricter fruit fly controls on imported cherries

“We are not at ease”: Demands for stricter fruit fly controls on imported cherries

Aníbal Caminiti calls for greater oversight of Chilean fruit to protect the country’s "fruit-fly-free" status, amid a late harvest and concerns regarding taxation.

The Argentine Fruit Committee—which includes Federcitrus, CAPCI, CAFI, the Argentine Blueberry Committee, the Pecan Association, the Mendoza Dried Fruit Association, and the Kiwi Chamber—was represented at Argentina’s first International Food Fair. During the event, Aníbal Caminiti, president of CAPCI, spoke with +P about sanitary controls, competition from imported fruit, the cherry season, and the sector’s grievances toward the national government.

When asked whether they felt confident regarding the sanitary safety of imported fruit, the response was unequivocal: “No. That is why we remain in constant contact with Senasa [the national sanitary authority] and are urging them to step up their oversight.”

Below is the full interview:

– What sanitary and commercial risks do cherry imports pose?
From a commercial standpoint, Argentina’s market is open to cherry imports, meaning there are no restrictions. Regarding sanitary issues, we worked with Senasa last year, and discussions with officials in Buenos Aires have continued this year. This week, we addressed these matters to strengthen controls—not only regarding sanitary standards but also concerning residue limits.
In humid, challenging environments, agricultural producers often increase the application of sanitary products. Therefore, we must insist on food safety—ensuring that any incoming product meets all requirements. This is a concern for us, and we are working with Senasa to address it.

– Are there checks in place to ensure that imported fruit is free from fruit flies?
Yes. There is a close relationship between Senasa and Chile’s SAG; they share information and conduct monitoring. The SAG assigns codes to the fruit, ensuring traceability back to the production site and the original packing facility. We are particularly concerned about Chilean fruit entering Patagonia—which is a pest-free zone—and we urge Senasa to tighten these controls. Fruit produced in a pest-free area may be packed in an infested zone, provided the packing facility is certified as a “bubble” (secure/isolated) packing unit. The same applies in Argentina. If such a facility is overseen by the SAG in Chile or Senasa in Argentina, the fruit is permitted to enter a pest-free zone—for instance, reaching Mendoza. If a container or shipment is opened within a “bubble” packing unit, the fruit can continue its journey to Patagonia, as the sanitary oversight chain remains intact. Conversely, if the goods are opened at a market in Buenos Aires, they lose their sanitary status.

– Are you confident in this chain of controls?
No. That is why we maintain constant contact with Senasa and push for stricter oversight. We receive a very positive response from the relevant authorities in Buenos Aires, and we work together. We know that gaps can always emerge, so we remain vigilant. We are also aware of the potential vulnerabilities within our own sanitary barrier system.

Competing on Equal Terms
– What is the sector’s view on the opening of the market to imports?
We are not concerned about competition itself. What concerns us is not having the same conditions to compete on an equal footing. Fruit from third countries is allowed to enter, yet our direct and indirect production costs are higher—a consequence of the public administration, including a heavy tax burden and other costs beyond our control. We can be efficient, but we lack equal opportunities. Within our own gates, we do everything we possibly can; beyond that, however, there are logistics costs that are out of our hands. We find ourselves in a small market that is easily saturated with fruit, which in turn impacts the returns to the producer. Furthermore, the fruit that enters may be of a different nature or quality; while it can be monitored for sanitary compliance, it may lack flavor or sweetness. This makes it cheaper, and we are then forced to compete against it. Most consumers make their choices based on price, and that drags us down in the market.

A Season That Started Late
– The harvest began later than usual. How does this affect the commercial window in relation to Chile?
It has a negative impact, because the great opportunity lies in getting to market early. In the Valle Medio region, early varieties should typically be ready around October 25th or 26th, yet the harvest only just began this week. This is a significant delay, caused by low temperatures linked to the El Niño phenomenon. It pushes us out of the early-season window and also delays the subsequent varieties. We are entering the market later than Chile—our main competitor—at a time when it is already in full swing, with significant volumes of Chilean fruit arriving. We are at a disadvantage. On the positive side, the sector has been receiving inquiries from various international markets regarding cherry demand. So far, volume projections and fruit quality look good, though they remain dependent on day-to-day weather conditions. Importers are seeking higher-quality fruit and are looking to Argentina as a source.

– Does the projection of 7,000 tons for export still hold?
Yes, it does, though the outlook—especially for December—is not very encouraging.

– What is the main phytosanitary challenge during the harvest?
The forecast for rain in the middle of the season, just as the fruit reaches its final stage of maturity. This can cause the fruit to split—rendering it unfit for sale—and increases the risk of post-harvest fungal issues. There is no support from SENASA for this; each company must rely on its own phytosanitary plan, which needs to be intensified under these conditions. It is the responsibility of each individual producer, company, and packing facility, depending on how they manage operations in the orchard and subsequently handle the fruit at the packing stage.

Demands on the Government
– If you had five minutes with Luis Caputo or Javier Milei, what would you bring up?
First, the high domestic cost of production in Argentina. Under the current administration, we continue to face a heavy tax burden and high energy costs. While we agree that utility tariffs need to be adjusted to reflect their true cost, the rates for packaging facilities and cold-storage plants are extremely high—and they are subject to a 27% VAT. We are requesting that, at least during this adjustment period, the VAT be reduced by half. Second, there is the issue of logistics. Transporting a container from Patagonia to Buenos Aires by land costs as much as shipping it by sea to Europe. In the cherry sector, we compete with Chilean fruit, which not only has lower production costs but also benefits from cheaper logistics—shipping from Santiago to Buenos Aires costs less than moving goods from Patagonia to Buenos Aires. Third, labor issues: although a labor reform has been enacted, it has not led to significant improvements for the fruit sector, so we continue to raise these concerns. Furthermore, the national government still has significant outstanding debts to the sector.

– What response did you receive regarding export rebates?
We have been discussing these rebates in meetings with officials from the Ministry of Economy. At the government’s request, industry associations have revised the economic studies they previously submitted and are now presenting them again. The fruit sector is asking for the rebates to be restored to their former levels—around 8%. Currently, for cherries, the export rebate ranges between 1.5% and 2.5%, depending on the type of packaging. The pome fruit sector (apples and pears) receives the highest rate, at 4.5%. These rebates serve as an indirect way to offset the tax burden, but at present, they fall short of doing so. While these figures could impact fiscal deficit policy, it is important to note that the fruit supply chain supports over 300,000 jobs nationwide and serves as a key driver for many small regional economies. We urge that the analysis not be limited to the foreign currency generated by the supply chain—because that amount is small: in 2025, the sector accounted for barely 2% of the country’s foreign currency earnings. Yet, underlying this is a significant social and employment impact.

– Do you think the government is open to that kind of analysis?
So far, no.

Market Access
– What kind of response have you received regarding market access?
Things are moving—perhaps not at the pace or in the way we need—but there is a different attitude and a new approach. Over the last three years of this administration, no new markets have been opened, but significant progress has been made in negotiating bilateral agreements and free trade treaties. Mercosur is in talks with markets like India and South Korea; however, reaching a collective agreement is difficult due to the asymmetries and conflicting interests among the bloc’s member nations. That is why the focus has shifted toward bilateral relations. These are long-term initiatives. We often compare ourselves to countries like Chile or Peru, which are highly agile because they maintain a consistent state policy on international and commercial relations—one that remains in place regardless of which political party is in power. In our case, whenever the administration changes, negotiations stall. With Mexico, for example, we’ve been trying for decades, and only now is real work being done. The current approach is well-aligned with our needs, and we hope it will be sustained by the next administration.

The State of the Roads
– How do you envision the harvest season, given the current state of the roads?
The situation in the Valley is already chaotic, but the roads are in poor condition everywhere. In parts of Patagonia, they’ve had to open 50-kilometer stretches of gravel track alongside the main highway because the road itself has become completely impassable. This isn’t a recent development; it’s the result of years of various national administrations leaving projects unfinished. Restoring the road network requires both budget and time, but the most serious issue is that the fundamental decision to act has yet to be made. Compounding this is the activity from the oil sector—with heavy trucks transporting materials—alongside the peak harvest season for pears and apples. The worst part is that we’ve simply grown accustomed to it.

Source: Más Producción

Compartir

Noticias Relacionadas

Compartir

Otras noticias